Geneva Symposium Exposes the Myth of Gunkanjima as ‘Hell Island’

(Click here to read this article in Japanese.)

 

 

A symposium held in Geneva Switzerland on July 2 sought to set the record straight concerning allegations by South Korea that conscripted workers from the Korean Peninsula were subjected to horrendous, discriminatory conditions while engaged in forced labor during World War II

 

The location, according to South Korea’s charges, was a coal mine on Hashima Island (commonly known as Gunkanjima or “Battleship Island”). 

 

The Gunkanjima controversy has received global attention following the designation of the island in Nagasaki Prefecture as a UNESCO World Cultural Heritage site. The symposium, organized to coincide with deliberations of the UN Human Rights Council, was sponsored by the International Research Institute of Controversial Histories (iRICH), a private sector group dedicated to establishing actual historical facts. The group is headed by Eiji Yamashita, professor emeritus at Osaka City University.

 

Former residents of the now uninhabited island participated in the symposium held at the United Nations Office in Geneva. They testified that to the best of their knowledge the Koreans had not been treated differently from other miners, while a South Korean scholar flatly declared that there was “no racial discrimination concerning wages.”

 

Dotoku Sakamoto, 65, a former island resident whose father was a coal miner, repeated what his father and former island residents had told him. “They said that they had considered their coworkers from the Korean Peninsula as friends who they would drink together with.”

 

Sakamoto added that the island’s reputation had been damaged by false representations that were spread about conditions at the time that portrayed the Koreans as essentially slave workers trapped on a “hell island akin to Auschwitz.”

 

A video was also shown during the symposium in which numerous former islanders testified.

 

Lee Wo-youn, a researcher at the Naksungdae Institute of Economic Research in Seoul, also spoke at the symposium. He said that based on his survey of wages paid by coal mines in various parts of Japan during the Second World War, he had concluded, “Monthly pay of Korean coal miners was high compared to what Koreans and Japanese doing other jobs were earning.”

 

Lee also decried the fact that a “distorted perception of history” portraying the Korean workers as slave laborers was being spread.

 

Plaintiffs have lambasted Japan’s alleged “human rights violations” in the “conscript labor” lawsuit now being pursued in South Korean courts, and pushed the issue internationally.

 

Kunitoshi Matsuki, senior researcher at iRICH, said, “Our institute’s position is that the allegations that the Japanese government dragooned Korean workers as slave laborers have no basis in historical fact. It is nothing more than perverted, anti-Japanese propaganda.”

 

Pauline Rubaz, a 30-year-old Swiss architect researching Gunkanjima, found the symposium fascinating. “It is difficult for Europeans to take a position in this dispute between Japan and South Korea,” she admitted. “But each nation should present its own views clearly to international society.”

 

 

(Click here to read the article in its original Japanese.)

 

Follow this link to read additional stories related to Gunkanjima (Hell Island)

 

 

Author: Mina Mitsui, Chief Correspondent, The Sankei Shimbun Paris Bureau

 

 

Mina Mitsui

Author:

Mina Mitsui is chief correspondent of the Sankei Shimbun Paris bureau. She has started her journalistic career at the Yomiuri Shimbun, and was Paris Bureau Chief (2011-2015) and Jerusalem Bureau Chief (2006-2009). She published several books; “Islam in Europe” 2015 Shincho-Sha, (Chinese translation published in Taiwan, 2017).

1 Comment

  • A South Korean scholar flatly declaring that there was “no racial discrimination concerning wages” exemplifies how race (and racism) no longer has its original meaning. If the idea is to label one ethnic population as a unique race, it’s already extremely tenuous as Japan has had those of Chinese, Korean, and other various ethnicities among its people for many generations.

    But what’s really disturbing is how far the human rights activists’ manipulation of Japan’s Annexation record has gone. People must realize that in addition to the US$800 million financial assistance was given by Japan to South Korea, what had belonged to Japanese interests including many corporations were abandoned and given away to the Koreans in 1965. The sheer extent of such handing over of capital, raw materials and products, technical know-how, and infrastructure cannot be underestimated: https://michaelyon-online.com/forced-to-work-or-forced-to-pay-over-and-over-again-until-perpetuity.htm

Leave a Reply