Connect with us


South Korea Alleges Conscripted Workers, but Japan Has the Facts



Prime Minister Shinzo Abe receives a letter of South Korean President Moon Jae-in from his special envoy Moon Hee-sang (left) on May 18th at Tokyo



In a meeting on May 17, Moon Hee-sang—special envoy of South Korean President Moon Jae-in to Japan’s House Representative—told secretary general Toshihiro Nikai of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP): “While we continue to confront the history issue, it is important to maintain a future-oriented focus.”


It seems that Korea is still willing to play the history card, in line with the domestic political situation.


Speaking in a separate meeting on the same day, this time with Japanese Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida, special envoy Moon talked about the “final and irreversible” resolution outlined in the Japan-South Korea Comfort Women Issue Agreement: “The feeling is that the majority of Korean People find it unacceptable.”



Indeed, in a phone conversation with Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on May 11, President Moon himself used an almost identical expression: “The majority of Korean People find it unacceptable on an emotional level.”


For South Korea, “confronting the history issue” involves making demands of Japan and causing a ruckus, but remaining unconcerned when they themselves break an international agreement. Of course, we should no longer be surprised by this.


Nevertheless, an article in Sankei Shimbun newspaper’s May 11 morning edition indicated that the next target after the comfort women issue, is the “Issue of Laborers Conscripted during the Japanese Reign of the Korean Peninsula.”


Following this, we received a request from a 45-year-old male reader from Yokohama to write a thorough report on an Asahi Shimbun newspaper article from July 13, 1959, and the contents of the Diet’s question time on October 1, 2010, with LDP House Representative Sanae Takachi (current Minister for Internal Affairs and Communications).



In fact, Sankei newspapers have reported on this at least three times before, but I would like to give a brief overview here.


The Asahi newspaper article, based on a press release from the Foreign Ministry, ran with the headlines “Majority Freely Decide to Remain - Foreign Ministry and Korean Residents Announcement,” and “245 People Conscripted During Wartime.” The article states:




“The Korean government and so forth are committing slander stating that Since the majority of Korean residents were brought to Japan as forced labor by the Japanese Government during the war, now they are being sent back because they are no longer needed.



“There are 610,000 Korean residents in Japan, however, of these, no more than 245 individuals were brought to Japan as conscripted work force.”




Moreover, although the Ministry of Foreign Affairs initially said, “Such old records no longer exist,” Mr. Takachi searched for the original reference materials, which were the basis of the article, and subsequently raised the issue during Diet question time.


The materials, which were the result of “investigating the circumstances of every single entry” of the 610,000 registered Korean residents at the time, clearly state the following:





 “The misunderstanding and slanderous remarks being propagated in some circles, such as the notion that the Koreans who came to Japan during wartime and the majority of those Koreans living in Japan at the present time were brought over as forced labor, are not in line with the facts.”


 “[Amongst Korean residents] the number of individuals that were conscripted as laborers by government decree is very small. These individuals were paid wages prescribed at the time.”





The Korean Citizens’ Group, which is currently planning to erect statues of conscripted laborers in front of the Japanese Embassy in Seoul, the Japanese Consulate in Busan, and Gwanju Station, is not necessarily referring to the former conscripted laborers residing in Japan.


However, the issue of Korean conscripted laborers is not unrelated to the myth of forced laborers, the notion that Korean residents in Japan are the descendants of forced laborers.


It is the Korean side which continues to cultivate the factually false, victim image, saying that Koreans were forcefully brought to Japan as unpaid slave labor—a history issue that needs to be confronted. That is why Japan needs to relentlessly continue to promote the facts as supported by the actual records.




Rui Abiru is an editorial writer and political section editing committee member of the Sankei Shimbun



(Click here to read the original article in Japanese)


Continue Reading
1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Anaximanders Ghost

    June 5, 2017 at 5:54 pm

    Let's be quite clear on this fact : The Korean neo fascist and communist factions can play the history card because THEY CAN.

    Japanese official and unofficial response has been one of the most inept of any in recent memory save perhaps North Korea.

    One need only look at the use of historical attacks as substitute or augmentation for real foreign policy to see how other nations are able to handle it. Many either ignore the charges, or effectively counter thrust. Something that is all to easy in the matters the Koreans, Chinese, and Japanese radicals bring up.

    But it is the very simplicity of a viable response that is the most damning condemnation of the current competence of the Japanese leadership in government, academia, and responsible press.

    Japan seems to be in the grips of a "GHQ Baby" mentality. Leaders hope that the US will save Japan as they have done for 70 years and all the people have to do is keep quiet and all will be well.

    Unfortunately this "head in the sand" approach is almost decades out if date. Starting in the mid 1990s the Chinese promotional machine began a methodical influence operation in the US. Japanese leaders at the time we're warned yet refused to take a responsible counter action.

    Then when the radical Korean nationalist joined with leftists in Japan and Korea to promote the Comfort Women issue, Japan again displayed gross negligence. Failing at every easy opportunity to highlight both the origin of the tale, as well as highlight the truth.

    Japanese are far more comfortable fighting each other than fighting for each other. That truth of modern day Japan needs to be understood.

    And so today you have a self inflicted wound where Japan both created and allowed to grow historical narrative that has paralyzed administrations, caused geopolitical rifts, and is making the world see the Japanese as a bunch of barbarian rapists.

    So who can honestly blame Korea, which has an ineffective and corrupt government / chaebol system, from taking advantage of "the big rich dummy" next door? It's only natural in the high stakes game of foreign policy to take advantage of the weak and weak willed, despite the platitudes the modern liberal order cheerleaders.

    Japan made its bed through neglect and incompetence, now she is forced to sleep in it.

    It will be a long dark night indeed for Japan is showing no sign she has learned from her mistakes regarding public relations in the modern world.

    Ryoma and Katsu Kaishu are indeed dead, and MacAuthur will not rise to save Japan. If the younger generation can not throw off the decrepit GHQ Babies running the store, there is little hope for real change. Korea will continue to run circles around the Japanese and MoFA.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply